Bagels and spreads

Bagel flavors: common types and what goes with each

Published 5 min readBy the Enfield Morning Notes team

Six different bagels in a row: plain, sesame, poppy, cinnamon raisin, everything, onion
Illustration made for this guide, not a photo from Benson's Bagels.

Short answer

Common bagel flavors fall into plain and seeded, savory seasoned, sweet and cheese types. Plain, sesame, poppy and everything suit savory fillings, while cinnamon raisin and blueberry suit butter or sweet cream cheese, and cheddar types suit eggs.

Common bagel flavors fall into four groups: plain and seeded, seasoned savory, sweet and cheese. Plain, sesame, poppy and everything suit savory fillings, while cinnamon raisin and blueberry suit butter or sweet spreads. Matching the flavor to the topping is the simplest way to choose a good bagel.

What are the most common bagel flavors?

The most common bagel flavors are plain, sesame, poppy seed, everything, onion, garlic, whole wheat, pumpernickel, cinnamon raisin and blueberry. Most shops bake some version of these, with extras that vary by region.

Flavor Group What it tastes like
Plain Plain Mild, malty, chewy
Sesame Seeded Nutty, toasty
Poppy seed Seeded Earthy, mild crunch
Everything Savory seasoned Salty, onion, garlic, seeds
Onion Savory seasoned Sweet, sharp onion
Garlic Savory seasoned Pungent garlic
Whole wheat Grain Nutty, heartier
Pumpernickel Grain Dark, slightly sweet, earthy
Cinnamon raisin Sweet Warm spice, sweet fruit
Blueberry Sweet Soft, fruity
Cheddar or jalapeno cheddar Cheese Savory, rich, sometimes spicy

What are plain and seeded bagels?

Plain and seeded bagels are the base styles: a plain bagel has no topping, and seeded bagels are covered with sesame or poppy seeds. They suit nearly every spread.

Plain is the most flexible, since its mild taste fits both sweet and savory toppings. Sesame has a toasty flavor that suits cream cheese, eggs and tomato. Poppy seed is mild and works with plain cream cheese or butter. A water bagel is simply a plain bagel in some regional wording.

What are savory seasoned bagels?

Savory seasoned bagels include everything, onion, garlic and salt bagels, and they are coated or filled with dried flavorings that toast during baking. They are best with creamy or salty toppings.

  • Everything: sesame, poppy, onion, garlic and salt. Good with plain cream cheese, lox and egg.
  • Onion: a sweet, sharp flavor. Good with cream cheese and tomato.
  • Garlic: strong and pungent. Good with plain cream cheese or butter.
  • Salt: large salt crystals on top. Good with butter.

These bagels taste so strongly of onion and garlic that they overpower a delicate topping. Pair them with ingredients that can hold their own.

What are sweet bagels?

Sweet bagels are made with sugar, fruit or spices in the dough, including cinnamon raisin, blueberry, chocolate chip and cranberry. They are meant for sweet or neutral toppings.

Cinnamon raisin is the best known. It goes with butter, plain cream cheese or honey cream cheese. Blueberry and cranberry suit plain or strawberry cream cheese. Peanut butter and jelly works on a plain or cinnamon raisin bagel, and many shops sell a bagel with peanut butter and jelly as a simple snack.

What are cheese bagels?

Cheese bagels are baked with cheddar or other cheese in the dough or sprinkled on top, which toasts into crisp, salty patches. Jalapeno cheddar adds a mild heat.

These bagels are strongly flavored and are often eaten with only butter or a light spread. They also work well as breakfast sandwiches with egg, because the cheese is already part of the bread. They are rarely a good base for sweet toppings.

Which toppings go with which bagel flavor?

The simple rule is to match a savory bagel with a savory topping and a sweet bagel with a sweet one. Plain bagels are the exception, since they suit both.

Bagel Good with Avoid with
Plain Almost anything Nothing in particular
Sesame Cream cheese, egg, tomato Heavy sweets
Everything Plain cream cheese, lox, egg Jam, honey
Cinnamon raisin Butter, sweet cream cheese Deli meat, lox
Blueberry Plain cream cheese, butter Egg and cheese
Cheddar Egg, butter, tomato Sweet spreads
Whole wheat Avocado, veggie cream cheese Nothing in particular

What is the difference between an egg bagel and a plain bagel?

An egg bagel is made with egg in the dough, which makes it yellow, richer and a little softer. A plain bagel has no egg and a firmer, chewier bite.

Egg bagels are common in some regions and less so in others. They work well for sandwiches because the softer crumb holds fillings without tearing.

What about whole wheat, multigrain and pumpernickel bagels?

Whole wheat, multigrain and pumpernickel bagels are grain based flavors that taste heartier and nuttier than plain. They are made with whole grain flour, mixed grains or dark rye and a little molasses or cocoa for color.

Whole wheat has a nutty, slightly bitter edge that suits avocado, veggie cream cheese and peanut butter. Multigrain bagels carry seeds and grains inside and on top, so they have a more varied crunch. Pumpernickel is dark, slightly sweet and earthy, and it is a classic partner of lox, red onion and cream cheese. These bagels are denser than a plain bagel, so they hold heavy fillings well, although some people find them less chewy.

How many flavors does Benson’s Bagels offer?

Benson’s Bagels in Enfield, Connecticut, says on its DoorDash page that it bakes over 15 varieties of fresh bagels, but its full flavor list is not confirmed. Its item descriptions name examples including everything, cheddar, cinnamon raisin, sesame and jalapeno cheddar.

As of November 2026 the DoorDash menu lists a bagel with cream cheese at $4.99, a bagel with butter at $4.99 and a bagel with PG & J at $4.99, and a full dozen at $19.99 in flavors you pick. Call (860) 835-5327 to ask which flavors are baked that day. See the menu page and the hours and location page for details. Prices are from DoorDash and may differ in the shop. This is an independent guide and takes no orders.

How do you choose a bagel flavor?

Choose a bagel flavor by deciding first whether the filling is sweet or savory. Savory fillings call for plain, sesame, everything or cheese bagels, and sweet fillings call for cinnamon raisin or blueberry bagels.

  1. Decide on your filling or spread.
  2. Match the sweet or savory direction.
  3. If you want to try something new, start with a plain or sesame bagel.
  4. If you buy a dozen, mix two or three flavors so you can compare.

Ask the staff what was baked most recently. A bagel that is warm from the oven often tastes better than any flavor choice.

Common questions

What is the most popular bagel flavor?

Plain and everything are usually named as the most popular choices in American shops, with sesame, cinnamon raisin and whole wheat close behind. Popularity differs by region and by shop, and no single official ranking exists.

What is a water bagel?

A water bagel is a plain bagel boiled in water and baked without added seeds or egg wash. The term is used in some regions to mean the standard classic bagel, as opposed to flavored or egg bagels.

What is the difference between an egg bagel and a plain bagel?

An egg bagel is made with egg in the dough, which gives a yellow color and a slightly softer, richer crumb. A plain bagel has no egg and a firmer, chewier bite.

Are sweet bagels good with savory toppings?

Usually not. Cinnamon raisin, blueberry and chocolate chip bagels taste best with butter, plain or sweet cream cheese and peanut butter. Savory fillings such as egg, lox or deli meat clash with the sugar.

How many bagel flavors are there?

There is no fixed number. Shops commonly bake between 8 and 20, mixing classic flavors with seasonal ones. Benson’s Bagels says it bakes over 15 varieties, but its full list is not confirmed.


This article is general information from an independent guide, not from Benson's Bagels itself. For the store’s current details see hours and location.

More guides

Independent guide. Not the official website of Benson's Bagels.