
Short answer
An everything bagel seasoning recipe mixes equal parts white sesame seeds and poppy seeds with dried minced onion, dried minced garlic and flaky salt. A basic batch is two tablespoons of each seed and one tablespoon each of onion, garlic and salt.
An everything bagel seasoning recipe mixes white sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried minced onion, dried minced garlic and flaky salt. A basic batch uses two tablespoons each of sesame and poppy seeds, one tablespoon each of onion and garlic, and one tablespoon of salt. It takes five minutes and makes about half a cup.
What is everything bagel seasoning?
Everything bagel seasoning is a dry blend of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried onion, dried garlic and salt, based on the topping used on everything bagels. The mix is savory, salty and a little nutty.
Although it began as a bagel coating, the blend is now used on eggs, avocado toast, vegetables, popcorn, crackers and cottage cheese. It is sold in jars, but it is easy to make at home from pantry staples.
What ingredients do you need?
You need white sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried minced onion, dried minced garlic and flaky salt, with black sesame seeds as an optional extra.
| Ingredient | Amount | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| White sesame seeds | 2 tablespoons | Toast first for more flavor |
| Poppy seeds | 2 tablespoons | Use fresh seeds |
| Dried minced onion | 1 tablespoon | Not onion powder |
| Dried minced garlic | 1 tablespoon | Flakes or granules |
| Flaky salt | 1 tablespoon | Halve it for fine salt |
| Black sesame seeds | 1 tablespoon | Optional, for color |
Use dried minced onion and garlic rather than powders, because the larger flakes toast on a bagel and give the mix its texture. Powders dissolve and make a dusty, salty coating.
What is the basic everything bagel seasoning recipe?
The basic recipe is to combine all five ingredients in a small bowl or jar and shake or stir until evenly mixed. It makes about half a cup.
- Measure the sesame seeds, poppy seeds, onion, garlic and salt into a small bowl.
- Stir with a spoon until the ingredients are evenly mixed.
- Taste a pinch and adjust the salt.
- Transfer the mix to a clean, dry jar with a tight lid.
- Label the jar with the date.
If you want a deeper flavor, toast the sesame seeds in a dry skillet over medium heat for about a minute, stirring constantly, then let them cool before mixing.
What are the ratios if you want to change the flavor?
The ratios are easy to change: raise the seeds for a milder, nuttier mix, and raise the onion and garlic for a stronger, savory mix. Salt is best adjusted last.
| Style | Seeds | Onion and garlic | Salt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mild | 4 parts | 1 part each | 1 part |
| Classic | 4 parts | 2 parts each | 2 parts |
| Bold | 4 parts | 3 parts each | 2 parts |
| Low salt | 4 parts | 2 parts each | 1 part |
A part can be any spoon measure, as long as you use the same one for all the ingredients. Start with the classic ratio and change one ingredient at a time.
How much salt should the mix have?
Use about one part salt to four parts seeds for a balanced mix, and use half as much if you use fine salt instead of flaky salt. Salt should be a seasoning, not the main flavor.
Flaky or coarse salt gives the characteristic sparkle and crunch, and it dissolves more slowly. Fine salt packs tighter and tastes saltier by the spoonful. If you will use the seasoning on salted foods such as salted butter or cheese, use less salt in the mix.
How do you use the seasoning on a bagel?
To use the seasoning on a homemade bagel, press it onto the boiled, wet dough before baking. For a store bought bagel, spread cream cheese and sprinkle the mix on top.
- For baking, boil the bagels, then press each one top side down into a plate of seasoning.
- Bake as usual, until the seeds are golden brown.
- For a ready made bagel, spread butter or cream cheese first, because the seasoning sticks to it.
- Press the seasoning gently into the spread.
On homemade bagels, keep the oven temperature in check. Dried garlic and onion flakes brown quickly and can burn in a very hot oven.
How should you store the seasoning?
Store everything bagel seasoning in an airtight jar in a cool, dark cupboard, away from heat and steam. It keeps for several months.
Steam from a stove or a kettle can cause the flakes to clump, so keep the jar away from the stove. If the mix clumps, spread it on a tray and let it dry in a low oven for a few minutes. Seeds contain oils and go stale over time, so make small batches if you do not use the mix often.
What can you add to the basic recipe?
You can add dried chives, dehydrated bell pepper, caraway seeds, red pepper flakes or lemon zest for a different style. Each addition changes the flavor, so add small amounts first.
- Caraway seeds: a rye bread flavor.
- Red pepper flakes: a gentle heat.
- Dried chives: a mild, green onion note.
- Dried lemon zest: a fresh, bright note.
- Black sesame seeds: more color contrast.
Keep notes on your changes, so you can repeat a mix you like.
How does homemade seasoning compare with bagel shop seasoning?
Homemade seasoning uses the same ingredients as a shop’s everything bagel topping, but the amounts are set by you, and the mix is not baked onto a bagel until you do it. Shops typically bake the mix onto the bagel, which toasts the seeds and flakes.
Benson’s Bagels in Enfield, Connecticut, advertises over 15 varieties of fresh baked bagels, and its item descriptions name everything among the examples, but the full flavor list is not confirmed. As of November 2026 the DoorDash menu lists a bagel with cream cheese at $4.99 and a bagel with butter at $4.99. Ask about the day’s flavors at (860) 835-5327. See the menu page and the hours and location page for details. Prices come from DoorDash and may differ in the shop. This guide is independent and takes no orders.
Common questions
Can I make everything bagel seasoning without poppy seeds?
Yes. Use extra sesame seeds, or add black sesame seeds for the visual contrast. The flavor will be slightly nuttier and less earthy, but the seasoning still works on bagels, eggs and vegetables.
How long does homemade everything bagel seasoning last?
Kept in a sealed jar in a cool, dark cupboard, the mix stays good for several months. The flavor of the dried garlic and onion fades slowly, and the seeds can turn stale if they are old.
Is everything bagel seasoning the same as everything but the bagel?
The two names describe the same type of blend. Everything but the bagel is a trademarked name used by one brand, while everything bagel seasoning is the general term for the mix.
Do I need to toast the seeds first?
No, toasting is optional. Toasting sesame seeds in a dry pan for a minute gives a deeper, nuttier flavor, but the seasoning works fine untoasted, especially if it is baked onto a bagel.
Why is my seasoning too salty?
Fine table salt is saltier by volume than flaky salt, so a recipe written for flaky salt tastes too salty with fine salt. Use half as much fine salt, or taste first and add salt gradually.
Looking for the basics? Benson's Bagels address and opening hours are on the home page.
This article is general information from an independent guide, not from Benson's Bagels itself. For the store’s current details see hours and location.


