Bagels and spreads

Cream cheese flavors: common types and what to pair them with

Published 5 min readBy the Enfield Morning Notes team

Four small bowls of cream cheese: plain, chive, strawberry, veggie
Illustration made for this guide, not a photo from Benson's Bagels.

Short answer

Common cream cheese flavors are plain, chive or scallion, vegetable, strawberry, honey walnut and herb and garlic. Savory flavors suit plain, everything and sesame bagels, while fruit and sweet flavors suit cinnamon raisin, blueberry and plain bagels.

Cream cheese flavors range from plain to savory types such as scallion and veggie, and sweet types such as strawberry and honey walnut. Plain suits every bagel, savory flavors suit plain, everything and sesame bagels, and sweet flavors suit cinnamon raisin, blueberry and plain bagels.

What are the most common cream cheese flavors?

The most common cream cheese flavors are plain, scallion or chive, vegetable, strawberry, honey walnut, and garlic and herb. Most bagel shops and supermarkets sell a version of these.

Flavor Type What it tastes like
Plain Savory Tangy, creamy, lightly salted
Scallion Savory Mild onion, fresh
Chive Savory Delicate onion
Veggie Savory Crunchy, fresh vegetable
Garlic and herb Savory Garlicky, herbal
Strawberry Sweet Fruity, sweet
Honey walnut Sweet Sweet, nutty
Blueberry Sweet Fruity, mild

What is plain cream cheese?

Plain cream cheese is cream cheese with no added flavor beyond a little salt. It is tangy, creamy and neutral, which is why it works on every kind of bagel.

For lox, eggs and cucumber, plain is the safest choice. For sweet bagels it works as a creamy base under jam or honey. If you are trying a bagel for the first time, plain cream cheese lets you taste the bagel itself.

What are savory cream cheese flavors?

Savory cream cheese flavors include scallion, chive, veggie, garlic and herb, and sun dried tomato. They suit seeded and seasoned bagels.

  • Scallion: fresh green onion, for everything, plain and sesame bagels.
  • Chive: gentler than scallion, for plain bagels and tomato.
  • Veggie: carrot, celery, pepper and scallion, for whole wheat and sesame bagels.
  • Garlic and herb: good on plain or onion bagels with tomato.
  • Sun dried tomato: works with basil, cucumber and chicken.

Savory flavors work best on bagels that are not strongly seasoned. Very strong spreads on an everything bagel can taste crowded.

What are sweet cream cheese flavors?

Sweet cream cheese flavors include strawberry, blueberry, honey walnut, cinnamon and maple. They are usually mixed with fruit, jam or syrup and suit sweet bagels.

Strawberry is the best known. It works on a plain bagel as well as on cinnamon raisin or blueberry. Honey walnut adds a crunch and a soft sweetness that goes with raisin or whole wheat bagels. Sweet cream cheese does not suit a lox bagel or a breakfast sandwich.

Which cream cheese goes with which bagel?

Match savory cream cheese with savory bagels and sweet cream cheese with sweet bagels, and use plain for everything else.

Bagel Cream cheese pairing
Plain Any flavor
Everything Plain, scallion, veggie
Sesame Plain, veggie, chive
Onion Plain, chive, garlic and herb
Cinnamon raisin Plain, honey walnut, strawberry
Blueberry Plain, strawberry
Whole wheat Veggie, plain
Cheddar Plain, scallion

How do you make flavored cream cheese at home?

To make flavored cream cheese at home, soften plain cream cheese, stir in the flavoring and chill it for an hour. The method works for savory and sweet versions.

  1. Soften 8 ounces of plain cream cheese for 20 minutes.
  2. Add the flavoring: two tablespoons of chopped scallions or chives, or a quarter cup of finely chopped vegetables, or two tablespoons of jam or honey.
  3. Mix until smooth.
  4. Chill for at least an hour.
  5. Store in a covered container and use within about a week.

Chop vegetables very finely and pat them dry before mixing. Extra moisture makes the cream cheese watery.

How do you serve flavored cream cheese at a gathering?

To serve flavored cream cheese at a gathering, offer three or four flavors in small bowls with separate knives, and label each one. A balanced spread has two savory flavors, one sweet and one plain.

Set out a mix of bagels such as plain, everything and cinnamon raisin so guests can match their own flavors. Add small bowls of toppings such as sliced cucumber, tomato, red onion and capers. Take the cheese from the refrigerator about 20 minutes before serving so it spreads well, and keep a backup tub cold. Sweet and savory flavors should have their own knives, otherwise the flavors mix and the strawberry ends up tasting of onion.

Does flavored cream cheese cost more?

Flavored cream cheese often costs more than plain at a bagel shop, because the extra ingredients add cost, but the difference depends on the shop. Menus may charge for the spread separately.

Check the menu or ask at the counter before ordering a large quantity. A tub of plain cream cheese plus a few chopped additions at home is usually cheaper than a flavored tub.

Does Benson’s Bagels sell flavored cream cheese?

Benson’s Bagels in Enfield, Connecticut, lists plain cream cheese in its Novalox and Philly wrap descriptions and veggie cream cheese in its Californian wrap. As of November 2026 the DoorDash menu lists a side cream cheese at $1.99, an 8 oz tub at $5.99 and a 16 oz tub at $9.99.

Which flavors the shop sells in cups and tubs is not confirmed, so ask when you order. A bagel with cream cheese is listed at $4.99. See the menu page for the recorded items and the hours and location page for contact details. Prices come from DoorDash and may differ in the shop. This is an independent guide and takes no orders.

What are some unusual cream cheese flavors?

Unusual cream cheese flavors include jalapeno, smoked salmon spreads, roasted garlic, pumpkin spice, maple walnut and cookie dough. They are usually seasonal or specialty items rather than everyday choices.

Jalapeno cream cheese adds mild heat and suits cheddar or plain bagels. Smoked salmon spread blends fish into the cheese, so the bagel needs no separate lox. Pumpkin and maple flavors appear in autumn. Because specialty flavors change often, a shop’s list can differ from week to week. If you are curious about a flavor, ask for a taste before buying a whole tub, and avoid pairing a very bold spread with a very seasoned bagel.

How do you pick a cream cheese flavor?

Pick a cream cheese flavor by thinking about the rest of the bagel. If the bagel has seasoning, choose plain or a mild savory spread. If the bagel is sweet, choose plain or a sweet spread.

  1. Decide whether the bagel is sweet or savory.
  2. Choose plain if you want to add toppings such as lox or tomato.
  3. Choose a flavored spread if you plan to eat the bagel with no other filling.
  4. Ask for a sample if the shop allows it.

Common questions

What is the most popular cream cheese flavor?

Plain is the most widely sold flavor, with scallion or chive and strawberry usually next. Popularity varies by shop and by region, and there is no single official ranking.

What is veggie cream cheese?

Veggie cream cheese is plain cream cheese mixed with finely chopped vegetables, usually carrot, celery, red pepper and scallion. It is a savory spread that suits everything, sesame and whole wheat bagels.

What is the difference between scallion and chive cream cheese?

Scallion cream cheese uses green onion, which has a slightly sharper and more pungent flavor, while chive cream cheese uses chives, which are milder and more delicate. Both suit savory bagels.

Can you make flavored cream cheese at home?

Yes. Soften plain cream cheese and stir in chopped herbs, scallions, jam, honey or crushed nuts. Chill the mix for an hour to let the flavors blend, and use it within about a week.

Which cream cheese goes with lox?

Plain cream cheese is the classic choice with lox, because it adds richness without competing with the fish. Scallion or dill cream cheese are also popular, but strongly flavored or sweet types clash.


This article is general information from an independent guide, not from Benson's Bagels itself. For the store’s current details see hours and location.

More guides

Independent guide. Not the official website of Benson's Bagels.